Today was a day off from the tourist thing; we stayed at home (in the mothership), did some laundry and other cleaning, and worked on our campground rating system. This morning we did take about a 3.5 to 4 mile walk on the Montrose city trail system to knock the dust off and keep the rust away.
Our campground rating system has been very subjective and we wanted to go to a more objective evaluation system to keep things fair and avoid the fault of giving a low overall rating when there was only one thing that pissed us off about a place. We started by listing the things we like to see in a campground, we sorted these items into categories, then assigned a value to each category and item. We kept our system to a 1 – 10 rating and we will still list our pros and cons of each campground.
After working out an evaluation system we went back and rated some of the campgrounds we have stayed in recently and some of our favorite and least favorite campgrounds to see how the system worked. Of course we found an item or two we wanted to add and we made a few minor adjustments to our numbers to get something we felt was fair and unbiased. The system is still based on the things that John and Sandy Byrnes look for in a campground; we do not rate things that we don’t use like bathroom/shower cleanliness or laundry facilities as we seldom use them.
Our system is heavily weighted on the site we receive with up to 5.5 points available. The site is where we live and so it is the most important aspect of the campground to us. We rate the utilities provided (electric, water and sewer service), the surface (dirt, gravel or paved), the size (length and width), of the site, and the privacy of the location.
The campground facility as a whole is rated with up to 2.5 points available. Although our rating system is weighted on the site we received we have had some OK sites in campgrounds we will never go back to because of noise, lack of security or owners/employees who demonstrate they are not concerned about the reputation of their business. Our system evaluates the location of the campground (ease of access by local roads), the facilities ability to accommodate our motorhome and tow (interior roadways), noise (interior and exterior), the amenities available (pool, hot tub, games/activity centers) and the appearance and condition of the facility.
We also award one point based upon the campground’s location relative to activities we are interested in and if there is local shopping available for food, and supplies. This will always affect where we choose to stay but some sites are central to many more fun/interesting activities and shopping opportunities than other campgrounds.
After considering all of the above we will award up to one point based upon the value of the site and services. Campgrounds that we feel are overpriced based on the factors we evaluate will not receive a point, campgrounds that we feel are priced fairly or are a bargain will receive a point.